Rue 561 Bistro: Dry-Aged Steaks and a Family’s Vision in Toms River
Discover Rue 561 Bistro, a family-run BYOB in Toms River serving 45-day dry-aged Pat LaFrieda steaks and globally inspired dishes for any occasion.

The steak alone would bring me back to Rue 561 Bistro. But after dinner at this family-run Toms River BYOB, it was clear there were plenty of other reasons to return, starting with the truffled whipped ricotta and a squash gratin I haven’t stopped thinking about.

Behind the internationally inspired menu is a family’s effort to create the kind of restaurant they wanted close to home. It’s a place where you can bring a favorite bottle, settle into a conversation, and enjoy dinner without competing with loud music.
Rue 561 is just as inviting for a casual weeknight dinner as it is for birthdays, anniversaries, and other celebrations.
A Family’s Vision

Longtime chef and restaurateur Frank Crupi, formerly of Café La Strada in Staten Island, envisioned Rue 561 after more than two decades of living in Toms River. His daughter, Michele, and her husband, David Nelligan, help oversee business operations. Michele balances that role with her law practice, while David also enjoys being on the floor and welcoming guests.
Frank designed the restaurant from the ground up, including its kitchen layout and equipment. “It was his whole design. It was his whole vision,” Michele told me.
The name nods to his former restaurant: “Rue” means street in French, echoing the Italian “La Strada,” while 561 is the address. The menu draws on Italian, Asian, and French influences, with exceptional steaks always part of the plan. Frank attended school with Pat LaFrieda and knew exactly whose beef he wanted to serve.
An Opening Interrupted
The family purchased the property in fall 2019 and began preparing for an April 2020 opening. Then the pandemic brought those plans to a halt. A soft opening eventually came at the end of 2020, with the restaurant finding its footing in 2021. Since then, Michele says word of mouth has driven its local following.
Today, Frank, now 80, remains a daily presence. He continues to work with the chef on food ordering, while the family shares the responsibilities of keeping his vision moving forward.
Meet Chef Rob

Chef Rob began his hospitality career as a server, working his way through college before finding his calling in culinary school. By 23, he had earned his first executive chef position.
His career includes restaurants across the Jersey Shore, including Phillips Seafood and many years at Chart House in Atlantic City. He later joined Hard Rock’s opening team, overseeing in-room dining for 1,971 rooms, VIP service, and backstage meals for entertainers.
At Rue 561, his enthusiasm comes through in every dish and in his visits to the dining room, where he chats with guests and makes sure everything is just right.
“He really puts his heart and soul into everything,” Michele said.
From Truffled Ricotta to Dry-Aged Steak

Our dinner started with the silky truffled whipped ricotta, a dish that was practically licked clean. The "truffled" is in the honey, so it's just a subtle hint, not overpowering at all. It was definitely a standout dish and a strong start to our dining experience.

The steaks deserve their place in the spotlight. The family says its steaks are dry-aged for at least 45 days, and my 12-ounce Pat LaFrieda Prime New York strip, served with a 72-hour demi-glace, was fantastic- so tender, and that demi is to die for.

For seafood lovers, the seafood pescatore brings lobster, clams, mussels, and scallops together over tagliatelle. With that assortment of shellfish sharing the plate, it’s easy to see why the menu appeals to more than steak enthusiasts.

The spaghetti squash gratin was another standout, silky and luxurious with mascarpone, gluten-free béchamel, cheddar, and Pecorino Romano. Rich and comforting, it’s the kind of side dish that deserves just as much attention as the entrée.

When I asked Michele for her own favorites, she pointed to the octopus with chorizo, the charcuterie board, and a wedge salad that takes a different direction from the familiar steakhouse version. Made with baby iceberg and a sesame ginger vinaigrette, it’s one of the dishes she enthusiastically recommends. I've put all three on my list to try next time.

A tip for new guests: Michele recommends paying attention to the specials. That’s where seasonal ingredients and the week’s seafood selections give the kitchen room to try something new. The family emphasizes fresh purchasing and sauces made in-house, with seafood specials guided in part by what their supplier recommends that week.
A Personal Approach to Hospitality

Rue 561’s appeal extends beyond the food, with a quiet dining room, attentive service, and a BYOB policy that keeps a weeknight dinner or celebration more affordable. For more places to bring your own bottle, see our guide to BYOB restaurants near Point Pleasant.
Dietary needs receive personal attention, too. Michele, who has celiac disease, has emphasized separate cookware and careful preparation with the kitchen. “We really go out of our way to accommodate that when people come in,” she said. Guests should discuss allergies or dietary restrictions with the restaurant in advance.
Sunday Sauce and Holiday Gatherings
New at Rue is their Sunday Sauce Dinner, which brings the family’s Italian heritage to the table with a five-course experience. Begin with the chef’s rotating bruschetta and a choice of soup or salad, followed by a refreshing intermezzo. The centerpiece is Salsa Rossa ai Tre Maiali, featuring braised pork three ways in a hearty San Marzano tomato sauce with fresh basil, Pecorino Romano, and tagliatelle. Seasonal gelato with fresh berries and house-made whipped cream provides the finish, with options to add a charcuterie course or upgrade to Chef’s select dessert.
Celebrate at Rue
Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve are important nights at Rue 561. Michele says Christmas Eve offerings typically include seafood, although the evening is not generally presented as a traditional Feast of the Seven Fishes.
The restaurant space is perfect for small office parties and holiday gatherings, with menus tailored to the group. Its intimate setting and personal attention have made it a favorite with local businesses, according to Michele.
Whether you’re organizing a holiday dinner or simply choosing somewhere to go this weekend, Rue 561 offers plenty of possibilities. My advice: start with the truffled whipped ricotta, check the specials, and bring someone willing to share.
Plan Your Visit
Rue 561 Bistro
561 Fischer Boulevard
Toms River, NJ 08753
732-503-4308
Contact the restaurant for current hours, Sunday sauce service, holiday reservations, and private-party inquiries.
