Inside Two River Dairy in Manasquan

    Two River Dairy Brings Farm-Fresh Food and Old-Fashioned Milk Delivery Back to the Jersey Shore.

    ·August 2, 2026·6 min read
    Interior of Two River Dairy in Manasquan, New Jersey featuring locally sourced groceries, artisan foods, fresh produce, and refrigerated dairy products.
    The inviting interior of Two River Dairy in Manasquan showcases shelves stocked with locally sourced foods, artisan pantry items, fresh produce, and premium dairy products from farms and makers across New Jersey and the Northeast.

    In an era of supermarket aisles and grocery delivery apps, Two River Dairy is bringing something refreshingly different to Monmouth County: farm-fresh food with a personal connection to the people who produce it.

    Exterior of Two River Dairy in Manasquan, New Jersey with welcoming storefront and sidewalk sandwich board highlighting fresh local foods.
    The inviting storefront of Two River Dairy in Manasquan welcomes shoppers with a sidewalk sandwich sign showcasing fresh, locally sourced foods, prepared meals, and seasonal offerings.

    From glass-bottled milk delivered to your doorstep to locally baked bread, seasonal produce, homemade prepared foods, and products from dozens of small-batch makers, Two River Dairy has become much more than a dairy delivery service. It's a modern neighborhood market built around knowing where your food comes from.

    A Modern Take on Milk Delivery

    Owners Allison Fisher and Doug Christensen
    Allison Fisher and Doug Christensen, partners and owners of Two River Dairy, have created a neighborhood market and delivery service focused on farm-fresh foods, local makers, and sustainably sourced products.

    When Allison Fisher and Doug Christensen took over the dairy delivery business in 2023, they saw an opportunity to revive a tradition many people remember from childhood while expanding it into something much bigger.

    Today, customers can schedule one-time or recurring deliveries of:

    • Glass-bottled milk

    • Goat milk

    • Farm-fresh eggs

    • Fresh breads

    • Local produce

    • Prepared foods

    • Pantry staples

    • Homemade baked goods

    • Grass-fed beef, pot pies, quiche

    • Specialty dairy products

    Ordering is simple through their website, where customers can choose weekly, bi-weekly, monthly, or one-time deliveries. Reminder emails are sent before each delivery, making it easy to add last-minute items.

    The service has grown quickly, now completing more than 450 deliveries every week throughout Monmouth County, with seasonal delivery routes extending into Point Pleasant and Lavallette during the summer, as well as communities including Maplewood, Bernardsville, and Basking Ridge.

    Glass-bottled milk and specialty dairy products in the refrigerated case at Two River Dairy in Manasquan, New Jersey.
    Glass-bottled milk is one of the signature offerings at Two River Dairy, where customers can shop in-store or have fresh dairy delivered to their doorstep through the market's home delivery service.

    Built on a Passion for Better Food

    The vision behind Two River Dairy is shared by partners Allison Fisher and Doug Christensen, who bring very different professional backgrounds but a common goal: making it easier for families to access fresher, healthier food.

    Two River Dairy's passionate team that shares that same commitment to quality, customer service, and supporting local farms and artisan makers.
    Stacey Farrington, Flaviva Figliola, Allison Fisher, Raul Ruiz, Sarah Lambert

    They're joined by a passionate team that shares that same commitment to quality, customer service, and supporting local farms and artisan makers. Whether preparing fresh meals each morning, stocking shelves with carefully sourced products, or packing weekly delivery orders, every member of the Two River Dairy team plays a role in creating the welcoming neighborhood market customers have come to love.

    Allison Fisher and Doug Christensen, who both call Manasquan home, share a passion for helping families eat better while supporting local farms and small businesses.

    Before opening Two River Dairy, Allison spent five years working in gastroenterology. Watching more and more patients—many of them younger than expected—face serious digestive diseases inspired her to create a business centered around clean, minimally processed foods and complete transparency about where ingredients come from.

    Doug brings a background in finance and technology, helping guide the business's growth while sharing Allison's commitment to building relationships with local farmers, artisan producers, and the community. Together, they've transformed Two River Dairy into more than a neighborhood market, creating a modern farm-to-table destination and delivery service that connects customers with exceptional products from trusted local farms and artisan makers throughout New Jersey and beyond.

    Supporting Local Makers at Every Opportunity

    Jars of Two River Dairy's house-made mustard displayed inside the market in Manasquan, New Jersey.
    Apple Barrel Mustard has become one of the market's most popular products, earning a loyal following among customers throughout Monmouth County.

    Walk into the Two River Dairy market, and you'll quickly notice something different.

    Rather than filling shelves with national brands, the focus is on regional farms and small businesses.

    Many of the products come directly from local artisans and family-owned producers, including:

    • Fresh mozzarella and ricotta from Caldino's in Point Pleasant

    • Organic coffee from Fair Mountain Coffee Roasters in Atlantic Highlands

    • Organic teas and elderberry products from Siren Essentials in West Belmar

    • Sweet Bee Cookies by Claire Theodore in Red Bank

    • Stacey Farrington at Apple Barrel Mustard makes the mustard and jams

    • Organic Bites products by Sue Deegan

    • Two River Gourmet Mushrooms

    • Seasonal fruits and vegetables from regional farms

    • Local raw honey and spreadable honey from Neshanic Valley Beekeepers

    • Grass-fed meat and poultry from Griggstown Farm

    That commitment to supporting local businesses extends to the prepared food case as well. Two River Dairy proudly carries Fit Food, the chef-crafted, healthy prepared meals created by local chef Jay Russo.

    Even products sourced outside New Jersey come from carefully selected small producers, including creameries in New York and artisan farms in Pennsylvania.

    "We're not ShopRite. We're not Whole Foods either," Allison said. "I know where my food's coming from, and that's so important."

    Fresh Food Made In-House Every Day

    Two River Dairy's house-made chicken salad featuring greek yogurt instead of mayo
    Two River Dairy's famous house-made chicken salad featuring Greek yogurt instead of mayo

    The prepared food case has become one of the shop's biggest draws.

    Everything is made fresh without preservatives, using ingredients the owners intentionally source for quality rather than convenience.

    Popular items include:

    • High-protein chicken salad made with whole milk Greek yogurt instead of mayonnaise

    • Egg salad featuring the store's signature mustard

    • Fresh pasta salads

    • Grain bowls

    • Burrito bowls

    • Seasonal peach and watermelon salads

    • Fresh vinaigrettes made with local honey

    • Homemade quiches

    • Daily breakfast offerings

    One standout philosophy is the decision to avoid seed oils whenever possible while emphasizing whole ingredients.

    Their house-made mustard has also developed something of a cult following, with hundreds of bottles sold since opening.

    Breakfast has become another favorite, featuring protein-packed egg bites made with cottage cheese and fresh vegetables alongside freshly baked breads and pastries.

    Fresh Bread, Better Dairy, Incredible Ingredients

    Fresh gluten-free breads on display at Two River Dairy & Market
    House-baked gluten-free breads on display at Two River Dairy & Market

    Bread lovers have plenty to choose from.

    The bakery offers sourdough, Asiago, walnut granary, olive bread, gluten-free loaves, and other baked goods prepared in-house from par-baked artisan dough.

    The dairy selection extends well beyond traditional milk, featuring:

    • Glass-bottled milk including A2 and Raw

    • Cream-top dairy products

    • Rich buttermilk

    • Whole milk Greek yogurt

    • Glass-bottled lemonade

    • Artisan butter

    • Premium ice cream

    Many of these products come from small family farms known for traditional production methods and exceptional quality.

    Returning the Bottle

    One of the most nostalgic aspects of the business is also one of its most sustainable.

    Customers receive a $2 credit every time they return their empty glass milk, goat milk, or lemonade bottles.

    The reusable bottle program reduces waste while bringing back a practice that many longtime residents remember from decades ago.

    More Than a Grocery Store

    Grocery haul from Two River Dairy & Market
    Grocery haul from Two River Dairy & Market including artisanal butter, gluten-free muffin, house-made chicken salad, spreadable honey, and Greek yogurt.

    Whether you're stopping in for fresh mozzarella, picking up breakfast, ordering weekly milk deliveries, or discovering a local artisan you've never heard of, Two River Dairy feels more like a community marketplace than a grocery store.

    It's a place where conversations happen over the cheese counter, where the people behind the products are often just a few towns away, and where shopping local extends well beyond produce.

    For anyone looking to eat fresher, support small businesses, or simply enjoy the return of glass-bottle milk delivery, Two River Dairy is proving that some old-fashioned ideas are worth bringing back.

    Two River Dairy & Market
    22 N Main St Unit 2B, Manasquan
    (732) 612-3191

    All stories